PERMANENT PEOPLES' TRIBUNAL

Second Session on the Philippines

 

Verdict:  GMA guilty as charged

 

March 25, 2007 Updated March 27, 2007

 

 

Bonus (Rewind) Tracks:  

 

The First PPT Session on the Philippines in 1980

 

 

 

 

 

 

The Permament Peoples' Tribunal (PPT2) rendered its verdict after four days of hearings and testimonies by video, hardcopy and video conferencing. GMA and others are guilty as charged.

 

"The Permanent Peoples’ Tribunal is an international opinion court. The victimized peoples and organizations submit their case to this tribunal when they have no access to a fair and just court of law. The trials and verdicts of the PPT have a strong moral authority and are resonant throughout the world.  Furthermore, the evidence and legal arguments collected and ventilated before the PPT can be used in the future to try Gloria M. Arroyo and her cohorts in various courts of law for criminal and civil liabilities."

 

-- Prof. Jose Maria Sison

 

Download text of the verdict in Word Format     ► Download statement of HUSTISYA

 

Visit the website of the Philippine Tribunal

Opening Day of Tribunal

Days1-4 of Tribunal

 

 

To download photo: Right Click on image and "Save Target as.."

To view actual size: Double click on image

If  some thumbnails are missing,    press F5 to refresh

 

           
screen shots
Mother Jastice with faces of martyrs      
           
           
           

Photos courtesy of Jan Beentjes

For more photos, go to

http://homepage.mac.com/rice.rights/ppt2

           
           
           
     
           
     
      ILPS Chairman Jose Maria Sison

Philippine Senator Jamby Madrigal

Tribunal Secretary General: Gianni Tognoni with KMU Chair Elmer Labog

 
Photos of the last day of the session on the Philippines courtesy of DB/RICE AND RIGHTS
           

PAN Artists at the Permanent Peoples' Tribunal on the Philippines

Photos and text courtesy of Jan Beentjes and People's Artist Network Website

           
Artists at the Peoples' Tribunal session on the Philippines The Mother Justice mural behind the jurors at the Permanent People's Tribunal Second Session on the Philippines

 

Artists from different fields gathered to express their support for the Permanent People's Tribunal (PPT) Second Session on the Philippines last March 21-25, 2007 in The Hague, The Netherlands.

The PPT on the Philippines was convened after families and relatives of victims of human rights violations in the Philippines filed a case against the President Gloria Macapagal Arroyo and her government.

Young visual artists Iman (17), Hiyasmin (15), Ilena (13) and Marikit (9) exhibited their works. They attended a visual arts workshop conducted by PAN founding member Martin Travers. The four young artists worked with Martin to create the Mother Justice mural for the Permanent People’s Tribunal Second Session on the Philippines. Martin Travers has worked with community groups in Palestine, Cuba, Mexico, Ireland, USA, London and The Netherlands.

Migrant community theater groups and guest artists also performed during the solidarity evening after the guilty verdict was announced. PAN founding members Jun and Mitchy Saturay helped put the program together.

DJ-activist poet John Sinclair graced the event with his presence and poetry.
 

PAN theater artist Mitchy with young Marikit
in a moving performance at the PPT
           

BAYAN-USA

Visit BAYAN-USA website for articles on the Permanent Peoples' Tribunal

http://www.bayanusa.org/

           
 
       
Statements and News items
           

 

PRESS RELEASE
International Coordinating Secretariat
Permanent People’s Tribunal (PPT)
Second Session on the Philippines
26 March 2007


ARROYO GUILTY OF CRIMES AGAINST HUMANITY
Tribunal Verdict to be transmitted to the UN, ICJ and European Parliament

THE HAGUE, Netherlands – In a 13-page verdict read before about 300 people inside a church in this city  March 25, the Permanent Peoples’ Tribunal (PPT) found both Philippine President Gloria M. Arroyo and U.S. President George W. Bush, Jr. and their respective governments as responsible for gross and systematic violations of human rights, economic plunder and transgression of the Filipino people’s sovereignty, were.

The verdict, read at the conclusion of the five-day second session on the Philippines by François Houtart, Session President, described the extrajudicial killings, forced disappearances, massacres, torture and other atrocities allegedly committed by the Arroyo government as “crimes against humanity”. Such violations which the PPT said were in no way justified as “necessary measures against terrorism”, must be stopped immediately.

In a cultural program held right after the verdict was read, Senator Jamby Madrigal said the Tribunal’s judgment will dispel the claims of the Arroyo government that there is democracy in the Philippines. The senator, who spoke as a resource person during the tribunal proceedings, said that the country is now ruled by a military junta with Mrs. Arroyo acting only as a figurehead.

The concluding part of the Tribunal took place at the Pax Christikerk in The Hague. The Hague is the Netherlands’ seat of government and the world’s center of international law. It hosts the International Court of Justice (ICJ), the new International Criminal Court (ICC) of the Rome Statute of 1998, and the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia (ICTFY) that tried Milosevic, the deposed president of Yugoslavia for war crimes.

The Tribunal, composed of six internationally-eminent persons, also named the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP), as having “a central role” in the atrocities, adding that the military is “a structural component and instrument of the policy of the ‘war on terror’ in the Philippines” declared by both Arroyo and Bush, Jr.

The verdict was rendered after three continuous session days that heard the testimonies of witnesses of political killings and abductions, expert testimonies and boxes of documents, and other evidences to support three major charges against the two governments. The charges were on: violations of the Filipino
people’s civil and political rights; economic, political, and cultural rights; and violations of the people’s rights to national self-determination and national liberation.

The number of victims of extrajudicial killings in the Philippines has reached 839 this week. Hundreds of others were victims of frustrated murders and abductions, widely believed to be perpetrated by government security forces. This report has been confirmed by the UN Special Rapporteur on extrajudicial, involuntary or summary executions, and by the government-created Melo Commission.

In the Tribunal, several testimonies of eyewitnesses, experts and resource persons were heard live through tele-video conference with Manila, with questions tossed by members of the Tribunal’s jury.

Those who gave depositions and testimonies either in person or through video hook-up included Marie Hilao-Enriquez, secretary general of human rights alliance Karapatan; Dr. Constancio “Chandu” Claver, victim of frustrated murder; Dr. June P. Lopez, an expert in handling torture and trauma victims; Navy Capt.  (ret.) Danilo Vizmanos; UP Faculty Regent Prof. Roland Simbulan; Bishop Elmer Bolocon of the UCCP and Ecumenical Bishops Forum (EBF); Elmer Labog, chair of Kilusang Mayo Uno (KMU); and Danilo Ramos of the Kilusang Magbubukid ng Pilipinas (KMP).

Senator Madrigal also appeared before the PPT as resource person on the environment.

‘Unacceptable’

The Tribunal jurors also denounced as “unacceptable” the inclusion of the Arroyo government in the UN  Human Rights Council (UNHRC). The Philippine membership, the jurors said, undermines the credibility of the United Nations particularly in human rights, and is “an intolerable offense” to the victims.

Aside from Houtart, who is from Belgium and Director of the Centre Tricontinental (Cetri), the PPT jurors  included Oda Makoto (Japan), well-known novelist and social activist; Ties Prakken (The Netherlands), professor in criminal law Maastricht University; Oystein Tveter (Norway), lawyer and former Director of the  Karibu Foundation and former foreign ministry official in South Africa and Zambia; Irene Fernandez (Malaysia), lawyer, social development expert and head of Tenaganita; and Lilia Solano (Colombia), 2005 Right Livelihood Awardee (alternative Nobel) and Director of Project for Life and Peace.

Richard Falk (USA), professor emeritus of international law at Princeton University and Hans Köechler  (Austria), president of the International Progress Organizations could not make it due to academic commitments.

Houtart and Makoto were also members of the jury during the first session on the Philippines in 1980 held  in Antwerp, Belgium, which found the Marcos dictatorship guilty for gross and systematic violations of human rights, among others. That verdict became a major factor in the international isolation of the Marcos dictatorship that eventually led to its ouster six years later.

PPT General Secretary Gianni Tognoni served as moderator of the proceedings.

Houtart said that although the verdict may be legally non-binding, it is nevertheless “morally binding”. The  judgment will be transmitted to the United Nations, the International Court of Justice, the European Parliament and various foreign governments. Tognoni said that the transmittal to these bodies will be a  major step toward focusing world attention on the human rights crisis in the Philippines. World opinion, the
PPT general secretary said, will add more pressure to the U.S.-supported Arroyo government to stop the  killings.


FOR REFERENCE:

Angelica M. Gonzales, MD
Executive Director, International Coordinating Secretariat
Permanent Peoples’ Tribunal (PPT)
Second Session on the Philippines
secretariat@philippinetribunal.org
www.philippinetribunal.org

 

Download press release in text format

 

===========================================

 

Int’l forum: RP gov’t responsible for slays Palace allies hit verdict as black propaganda

By Jocelyn Uy
Inquirer
Posted date: March 26, 2007

MANILA, Philippines -- A forum of lawyers and human rights activists meeting in The Hague found the administration of President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo responsible for unsolved killings and disappearances in the Philippines, according to a copy of its verdict sent to the Philippine Daily Inquirer late Sunday night.

Malacañang allies in the House of Representatives slammed the verdict as unfair and biased.

“The wealth and consistency of the oral and written documentation made available through witnesses and expert reports, has convinced the [tribunal] that each and all of the three charges presented against [Ms Arroyo] and her government and against [US President] George Walker Bush and his government are substantiated,” said the decision of the group called the Permanent People’s Tribunal. -->>>>

 

Statement of NDFP Human Rights Committe Chair

 INQUIRER: Tribunal verdict vs Arroyo to be sent to UN, int'l bodies

INQUIRER: Int'l forum: RP gov't responsible for slays

INQUIRER: Victims’ kin hail People’s Tribunal guilty verdict vs Arroyo

INQUIRER:Roots of the International People’s Tribunal

ABS-CBN: 'Arroyo regime worse than Marcos era’

GMAnewsTV:Leftists turn to Internet to spread word about killings

GMAnewsTV: Political prisoners start fast vs killings, arrests

CPP hails guilty international tribunal's guilty verdict on Arroyo and Bush governments

Oplan Bantay Laya: U.S.-Arroyo Regime’s ‘Final Solution’ by Capt. Dan Vizmanos

Against Impunity by Luis V. Teodoro

At the center of the universe - column by Patricia Evangelista

Inquirer - Roots of the Peoples' Tribunal

Karapatan - Dutch envoy insults the victims

 

 

Press Statement
26 March 2007

PERMANENT PEOPLES’ TRIBUNAL FINDS ARROYO AND BUSH GUILTY OF CRIMES AGAINST HUMANITY

By Prof. Jose Maria Sison
Chairperson, International League of Peoples’ Struggle

As chairperson of the International League of Peoples’ Struggle (ILPS), I wish to congratulate the Permanent Peoples’ Tribunal (PPT), the initiators, the distinguished jurors from various countries, the prosecutors, the plaintiffs and coordinators for their resounding success in the trial of the case of the Filipino people against the Arroyo regime and its imperialist accomplices from the five-day PPT proceedings from 21 to 25 March 2007 in The Hague, The Netherlands.

We hail as well-substantiated and just the verdict of the Permanent Peoples’ Tribunal finding the governments of Gloria M. Arroyo and George W. Bush, the International Monetary Fund, World Bank, World Trade Organization, the multinational firms and banks guilty of oppressing the Filipino people, plundering the Philippines and trampling down on Philippine sovereignty.

The accused oppressors and plunderers are guilty of the following crimes:

1. Violations of human rights, especially civil and political rights, with particular focus on extra-judicial killings, disappearances, massacres, torture as well as other vicious, brutal and systematic abuses and attacks on the basic democratic rights of the people.

2. Violations of human rights, especially economic, social and cultural rights of the Filipino people through the imposition of "free market" globalization to exploit them; transgression of their economic sovereignty and national patrimony; various forms of economic plunder and attacks on their economic rights; and the destruction of the environment.

3. Violations of the rights of the people to national self-determination and liberation through the imposition of the US war of terror; US military intervention; as well as the perpetration of crimes against humanity and war crimes; misrepresentations of the people's right to national liberation and self-determination as terrorism and the baseless "terrorist" listing of individuals, organizations and other entities by the US and other governments.

We are deeply pleased that the Filipino people and the organizations, HUSTISYA!, SELDA, Desaparecidos, Bagong Alyansang Makabayan (BAYAN, New Patriotic Alliance), KARAPATAN, Public Interest Law Center, Peace for Life, Philippine Peace Center, IBON Foundation, United Church of Christ in the Philippines and the Ecumenical Bishops Forum have won a meaningful measure of justice from the PPT trial.

As an organization dedicated to the cause of national and social liberation of the peoples of the world, we the ILPS are glad that the PPT verdict condemns the imperialist policy of profit-driven “free market globalization” and the Bush global war of terror. These are the motivations and cause of the brutal suppression of human rights in the Philippines.

We praise the PPT verdict for regarding as substantiated the charge against the Arroyo and Bush governments for violating Philippine national sovereignty. The charge includes the instigation of crimes against humanity under the Bush war of terror, US military intervention and the misrepresentation of the people’s right to national liberation and self-determination as “terrorism” and the listing and labeling of Philippine revolutionary forces and progressive leaders as “terrorist”.

We believe that the PPT verdict will have far reaching consequences. The record of the proceedings and the verdict will be published and will serve as substantial material for mass campaigns in the Philippines and abroad. They expose the crimes of the Arroyo regime and its accomplices and can further arouse and mobilize the Filipino people to fight for their national and democratic rights, with the support of the people of the world.

The Permanent Peoples’ Tribunal is an international opinion court. The victimized peoples and organizations submit their case to this tribunal when they have no access to a fair and just court of law. The trials and verdicts of the PPT have a strong moral authority and are resonant throughout the world. Furthermore, the evidence and legal arguments collected and ventilated before the PPT can be used in the future to try Gloria M. Arroyo and her cohorts in various courts of law for criminal and civil liabilities. ###

 

Download statement in Word format
 

====================

“The tribunal, having considered the evidence before it, is of the opinion that the reported killings, torture and forced disappearances fall under the responsibility of the Philippine government and are by no means justified in terms of necessary measures against terrorism,” it added.
 

A copy of the decision was e-mailed to the Inquirer Sunday night by the Philippine chapter of the tribunal secretariat through the human rights alliance Karapatan. Its secretary general, Marie Hilao-Enriquez, testified on the human rights situation in the country.

A seven-member jury of the tribunal heard charges against both the Philippine and US governments which, the verdict said, “colluded with each other in implementing the US’ so-called ‘war on terror’ in Southeast Asia.”

Leaders of the House majority said the Hague forum showed its “biased nature” by asking Sen. Jamby Madrigal to testify before the group.

House Majority Leader Prospero Nograles and Antique Rep. Exequiel Javier said in a statement that Madrigal’s testimony “was part of the intensified opposition black propaganda against the President.”

The tribunal, an independent body founded in 1979 in Italy by lawyers, writers and intellectuals, examines and judges complaints regarding violations of human rights submitted by the victims themselves or groups representing them.

The hearings were held in a church in The Hague.

The Philippine government has blamed the communist New People’s Army for most of the murders, saying the group was purging its own ranks.

The international community has voiced concern over the unresolved killings of hundreds of political activists in the country since Ms Arroyo took office in 2001.

The charges presented against both the Arroyo and Bush administrations included:

• Gross and systematic violations of civil and political rights: extrajudicial killings, abduction and disappearances, massacre, torture.

• Gross and systematic violation of economic, social and cultural rights.

• Gross and systematic violations of the rights to national self-determination and liberation.

http://services.inquirer.net/print/print.php?article_id=56941
Inquirer Headlines / Nation
 

 

 

           
BONUS (REWIND) TRACKS
           

 

The Permanent Peoples' Tribunal's first session on the Philippines convened from Oct. 30 to Nov. 3, 1980 at the University of Antwerp, Belgium. It examine the appeals presented by the NDFP and the MNLF on behalf of the Filipino people and Bangsa Moro people respectively. A book of about 300 pages documented the proceedings and decisions of the Tribunal.

 

           
Back Cover Contents RP map
    Introduction

<<-- Some photos of the sessions

List of the member jurors >>>>

         
           
           
           

 

Home

 

 
Web www.arkibongbayan.org